Please see Styx thread on the Registered Shipmates consultation for the main discussion forums - your views are important, continues until April 4th.

Ship of Fools: Hereford Cathedral, Hereford, England


imageShip of Fools: Hereford Cathedral, Hereford, England

Bright lights spoil the mood at this Epiphany service

Read the full Mystery Worshipper report here


Comments

  • Gee DGee D Shipmate
    I wonder how a triptych found its way from Swabia to Hereford in 1530, with the Reformation underway on the mainland and Henry getting his separation from Rome in England. Quite a journey

    How many were there in the nave please? It's unclear from your report.
  • Perhaps the triptych was bought after the Reformation and later still, given to the cathedral? Someone will know.
    There were roughly 500 in the nave.
  • Gee DGee D Shipmate
    Thanks - I misread you report as saying that the nave sat 500.
  • I'm afraid its not just the back of the nave, where you sat, that the lighting is worshipper unfriendly. Just four or five years ago Hereford spent a lot of money on a new lighting with LEDs, which is very green and probably reduced their bills.

    But the nave uplighitng from dozens of LEDs dotted about has a horror-show effect. Romanesque naves were supposed to be lit with divine light from ABOVE, not the other sort from below. The uplighting makes all the shadows flip upside down, like a disco. Plus the high level spotlights (and transept chandeliers) at Hereford can be dazzling, as you found, an effect worse for those wearing lenses or spectacles.

    Hereford is one of my very favourite English cathedrals, but it looks best with the lights off. It wouldnt work for a late afternoon service in Winter such as this, but at other times it might. My sight is far from 20:20 but I do question the idea that church services require light at the intensity of a retail outlet.

    I wonder if they couldn't 're-focus' the lighting—a term apparently used by lighting designers for tweaking the angles and brightness of lights—to reduce glare (though even this costs a lot at such giddy heights).

    Electricity is so often the enemy of a numinous atmosphere.
  • You've hit on something fundamental.
    I hissed to the friendly helper who lit my candle 'turn the lights out' and she assured me they would. But they didn't.
    I date the start of the decline in religion to the invention of electricity.
  • :lol:

    No, no - the invention of television, surely? Or the cinema?
  • The drum kit.
  • Especially the one enclosed in Perspex... :scream:

    Seriously, though, it's a shame if carefully thought-out special effects are spoiled by what appears to have been an error on someone's part! Maybe they'll do better next year...
  • I love Hereford Cathedral but have never visited in the winter. I'm so glad you used the photograph at the top of the page, showing Edward Elgar leaning on his bicycle and gazing at the Cathedral. (He's sometimes adorned with flowers for special occasions.)
  • PDRPDR Shipmate
    Church lighting is often a nightmare. It tends to err either on the side of dimness, or tries to achieve an intensity best suited to an operating theatre, with relatively few folks successfully shooting for the middle ground.
  • Indeed. There are quite a number of companies in the UK which specialise in good 'bespoke' church lighting, but I'm afraid they're not exactly cheap...
  • Clever candle holders in the Choir stalls at Ely have a genuine candle on top with a small electric light, shaded so that the light falls only on your book. You can't tell at all that the candle holders on the opposite side of the Choir hold anything but a candle. A cheat - but it works.
  • PDRPDR Shipmate
    Indeed. There are quite a number of companies in the UK which specialise in good 'bespoke' church lighting, but I'm afraid they're not exactly cheap...

    I think the church we worship in was OK until the previous owners decided to put curly bulbs in all the light fittings. The architects seemed to have a good idea of what was the required light level and arranged for 16 x 60w at the top of the nave columns, and then 6 pendant 150w lights suspended from the nave roof to illuminate a building which is basically 64' by 40.'

    Unfortunately, the high lights are now extremely bright thanks to the curly bulbs so that when you bang that lot on and you have enough light for neuro-surgery! I had the same problem with the low level lights, which had been changed to 100w equivalent curly bulbs. I changed out the low level lights for yellow LEDs and they are much more satisfactory. Sadly, on their own they are not quite enough, so I need to find someone I can bribe to go up a 20' ladder and change the rest!
  • Ah - one of the aforesaid Lighting Firms would no doubt oblige, for a few $$$...
    :grimace:
Sign In or Register to comment.