Purgatory : Kamala

Robert ArminRobert Armin Shipmate, Glory
edited April 2021 in Limbo
Jo Biden has selected Kamala Harris as his running mate. From what I've read, she sounds great, but I know very little about her (I'm a Brit). What do those of you who know more about American politics than I do think?
«13456

Comments

  • CaissaCaissa Shipmate
    Usually, the selection of a running mate in the US is designed to cement a certain percentage of the population without alienating another segment more. She is to the left of Biden yet not Bernie Sanders. She also helps to stop from siphoning off votes to Kanye West.
  • Jo Biden has selected Kamala Harris as his running mate. From what I've read, she sounds great, but I know very little about her (I'm a Brit). What do those of you who know more about American politics than I do think?

    Sen. Harris was my first choice for the nomination ... She's excellent ...
  • stetsonstetson Shipmate
    I believe she's a prosecutor, and from what I've seen on TV, has a fairly streetwise demeanour(albeit possibly somewhat affected). I suspect she will bolster the ticket's law-and-order credentials, especially if the GOP tries to have fun with Defend The Police and whatnot.
  • stetsonstetson Shipmate
    Correction...

    Sorry
    stetson wrote: »
    especially if the GOP tries to have fun with Defund The Police and whatnot.

  • CaissaCaissa Shipmate
    She also graduated from Westmount High in Montreal, class of '81.
  • vermillionvermillion Castaway Posts: 17
    Doesnt matter, Trump will get a 2nd term. Thanks to the anarchists and rioters.
  • Golden KeyGolden Key Shipmate, Glory
    Rolling Stone's take.

    Female, African American, and Californian!
    :cool:

  • ...and young enough to have a go at the Presidency herself one day, perhaps?
    :wink:
  • edited August 2020
    Who is the last women nominee? I think it was the awful grand ignorant Sarah Palin. Nixon was someone's vice president too I believe. But they were the parents of the current guy, at least intellectually. I don't think I have to look further than wikipedia to agree this woman would be better.
  • stetsonstetson Shipmate
    Who is the last Nixon was someone's vice president too I believe.

    Eisenhower.

  • I believe her mother is Asian, her father is Black, and her husband is Jewish. That covers a lot of votes. I am happy with the choice, and believe she will mop up the floor in the debates with our current vice president.
  • Maybe she should run for President, with Mr Biden as VP?
    :lol:

    Seriously, though, jolly good luck to the both of them!
    :wink:
  • Gee DGee D Shipmate
    Who is the last women nominee? I think it was the awful grand ignorant Sarah Palin. Nixon was someone's vice president too I believe. But they were the parents of the current guy, at least intellectually. I don't think I have to look further than wikipedia to agree this woman would be better.

    Nixon was Eisenhower's vice president. I'd imagine that Eisenhower thought very little of him.
  • Meanwhile, T is saying "some people" are saying men should be insulted that Biden chose a woman. (At the time Biden had yet to name Harris.) https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/politics/elections/2020/08/11/president-trump-some-say-men-insulted-joe-biden-choosing-woman-vp/3342664001/

    T certainly knows how to win brownie points, doesn't he?
  • Was Nixon regarded poorly in America before Watergate? I thought not, but could well be wrong.

    I really wanted Harris for the position of take-no-prisoners AG, prosecuting 100 Trump apparatchiks at a single bound et al. I'll take her as VP, and if she does good, President in her turn.
  • Nixon performed poorly vs JFK televisually (perspiring upper lip made him look nervous and unappealing, cf/ JFK), but substantively well. He was known as "Tricky Dick" before Watergate. He was not well loved, by any means. Whatever one thinks of him, his failing wasn't intellect but paranoia. He was, by all accounts, highly intelligent.

    On the topic of women, let's not forget that Geraldine Ferraro was Walter Mondale's running mate.
  • Golden Key wrote: »
    Female, African American, and Californian!
    :cool:
    Ironically, also the three things that the Trump Faithful will never forgive her for.

  • At one time California was a citadel for the Republican party, but as it has gotten more color, no more.
  • RuthRuth Shipmate
    Kamala Harris came out of San Francisco politics, as do many politicians successful at the state level in California, despite the fact that there a lot more people in southern California. SF politics are absolutely cut-throat, and if you can do well there, you can go far. California Gov. Newsom, House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, and Sen. Dianne Feinstein all come out of San Francisco. In San Francisco politicians learn how to fight and how to negotiate, they learn how and when to compromise, and they learn how to get things done with people they disagree with.

    Kamala Harris is tough, and I'm sure this was part of the equation when Biden was making his pick. An unbelievable amount of racism and sexism is coming her way.
  • Yep. I was looking at her opposition to the appointment of a special prosecutor to deal with police shootings. It struck me that her position was against her brand. It seemed like she would be well aware of the political damage such opposition would provoke, but did it anyway. This NYT article addresses the issue best from what I've seen so far, about an answer she gave during the Democratic debates. It says her opposition was because she didn't want to take the responsibility to investigate away from County DA's, who were directly accountable to local residents as elected officials.

    This strikes me as a really good sign about Harris' ethics as a politician. It strikes me that she knowingly took political damage to oppose legislation that she felt would not be good for the administration of justice.

    Before I become a fully paid up member of the I :love: Kamala Harris club, I'd be interested to hear CA shipmates views on this episode. Was she truly a fighter for truth, justice and the American way?
  • ...and young enough to have a go at the Presidency herself one day, perhaps?
    :wink:

    This is actually a very important consideration. At 77, Biden had to pick a VP who is ready, day one, to step into the presidency, if need be. And he needs someone he can pass the baton to if he decides not to seek a second term (which I think is likely).
  • Penny SPenny S Shipmate
    World Service said her mother was Native American. That would be even more irritating to the sort of people who are ready to be irritated if true. But good.
  • RuthRuth Shipmate
    Did they say "Native American" or did they say "Indian"? Her mother was from India. Her father is from Jamaica.
    Simon Toad wrote: »
    Yep. I was looking at her opposition to the appointment of a special prosecutor to deal with police shootings. It struck me that her position was against her brand.

    Her views have shifted to the left over time. She initially ran for San Francisco DA against a more liberal incumbent, saying he was soft on crime. Criminal justice reform has become far more popular since then.
  • Golden KeyGolden Key Shipmate, Glory
    Re Kamala possibly running for pres.:

    Willie Brown had an interesting take on this, several days ago, in his SF Chronicle article. He's been mayor of SF, speaker of the California Assembly (which we have instead of a House), and has done assorted other things. Very openly loves power, but at least you know that up front.

    "Willie Brown: Kamala Harris should say no to vice presidency" (SF Chronicle).

    Oh, and she did run for president this time around, but bowed out of the race.
  • Pay wall.
  • bugger. I cleared my cookies but they were too clever for me.
  • Penny SPenny S Shipmate
    edited August 2020
    I'm pretty sure they did not say Indian, as there were two words, and I wouldn't have thought they meant First Nation by using Indian, but I suspect someone may have made an erroneous edit, believing they were putting something right. It'll be interesting to hear what is said from now on.
    Definitely saying Indian this time.
  • Golden KeyGolden Key Shipmate, Glory
    Sorry, no sign of a pay wall for me. WB basically said there are downsides to being VP; sometimes it's a dead end; she'd be better off being Biden's attorney general; she could do some good there; and it would be a good position from which to run for pres. in 2024.
  • Most definitely told me to subscribe if I wanted to read.
  • DoublethinkDoublethink Admin, 8th Day Host
    I imagine it has crossed her mind that if Biden dies in office, vp is the quickest route to the presidency.
  • I was rooting for Susan Rice, same age, black woman, with much better credentials. I found Harris very unlikable during the debates, and thought she was roundly put in her place by Tulsi Gabbard.* She was extremely harsh toward Biden and her tendency to brag about her achievements in broad terms while misleading about specifics reminded me of Trump himself.

    I just can't understand this choice. At this moment in time when the BLM movement with talk about defunding the police is at its peak we're going to have a woman who was responsible for sending black men to prison in unprecedented numbers and for things like marijuana possession. Somewhere along the line, about the time she decided to run for president she changed from hard core law and order prosecutor to far left liberal and it all seems suspiciously sudden to me.

    During the debates she told a story about herself, "I was that little girl on a bus" that was obviously pre-planned, the T-shirts had been printed and were sold after the debate. It presented an image to Americans of a poor African-American child, a descendant of slaves rising up from poverty. The truth is she grew up with great privilege, her father was a college professor, an immigrant whose grandparents had been slave holders in Jamaica. Her mother was a surgeon, an immigrant from India. Kamala's high school years were all spent in Canada. Add to all this her beauty and looks that can pass for white and she's just not what black women are talking about when they talk about how hard it is to be black in America every minute of everyday.

    *https://youtube.com/watch?v=Cfp_IIdVnXs
  • Golden KeyGolden Key Shipmate, Glory
    Some people said Barack Obama wasn't black enough. Make of that what you will.
  • Obama didn't tell a story about himself, in a choked up voice, that implied he had grown up in poverty and experienced the type of discrimination that goes along with actually being perceived as black. He wasn't elected during the BLM, anti-police brutality movement with a history of sending black people to prison.
  • Golden KeyGolden Key Shipmate, Glory


    Anything about KH's racial experience and how bad it is/was is way above my pay grade. I'm just mentioning some thoughts, news stories, etc.

    I remember there was some controversy about what she said then. But if she really was bussed away to a white school*, it was likely a very difficult experience, and choking up is warranted.

    I'm not particularly defending K. Just saying there may be different angles from which to view her and her actions.

    The prepared t-shirts you mentioned? She was running for president, and that means planning strategies. It makes sense to me that she'd have her "bussed child" paraphernalia ready ahead of time.

    As to sending black men to prison, I saw something today that said she was the most progressive attorney-general California's ever had.

    I'm watching an excerpt of a show about Kamala on "ABC World News Now". Brief excerpt, but interesting. E.g., lived in Berkeley as a kid. Her Indian mom intentionally raised K and her sister as black women. Went to Howard Univ., one of the "Historically Black Colleges". Various college friends talked about her. One said that people often thought she and KH were professors, because they were all business and carried attache' cases. Etc.

    *Younger than high school, IIRC.
  • Golden Key wrote: »



    I remember there was some controversy about what she said then. But if she really was bussed away to a white school*, it was likely a very difficult experience, and choking up is warranted.
    She was speaking of it as a wonderful experience without which she wouldn't have become who she is today. It was part of her attack on Biden who had been against bussing for various reasons.

    With such wealthy and educated parents, I imagine she still could have become a lawyer, even without being bussed to another elementary school.

    It's those misleading aspects I objected to, as well as her attack on Biden, which practically called him a racist.

    I'm disappointed because Biden made such a point of saying that, in respect to this particular moment in history, he was going to choose a black woman as running mate. I thought the purpose for doing that was to have someone working with him who really understood, first hand, the problems of being black in America. I think most African Americans would agree that a large part of those problems stem from growing up in poverty and from having a black appearance -- which often results in racial profiling from those in power, from police to those in hiring positions. I just don't think Kamala Harris has had many of those experiences.

  • Gee DGee D Shipmate
    So, for whom are you going to vote?
  • I'd vote for Biden if Jerry Springer was his running mate. I don't hate Kamala, I just read Politico's 55 "Things you should know about Kamala Harris," and about half the things sounded good and half bad. She just wasn't my first pick and seeing the media fawn over her with pieces that look more like campaign ads than informative news is a bit hard to take.
  • I was looking around at various comments on Harris, and the right wing seem torn between labelling her a radical leftist, and an over-zealous prosecutor, who put lots of black men in jail. Also, from the left, that she's not black enough, is too affluent, etc. But surely she will get more of the black vote out than Hillary?
  • I was looking around at various comments on Harris, and the right wing seem torn between labelling her a radical leftist, and an over-zealous prosecutor, who put lots of black men in jail. Also, from the left, that she's not black enough, is too affluent, etc. But surely she will get more of the black vote out than Hillary?
    The problem with the American Left is that it is too fragmented and too idealistic at the wrong time. The American Right might be just as fragmented, but when it comes time to vote, they are more unified.
  • Not to sound too Bolshevik about this, but I have an impatience with the lack of disciple with the American left, viz, not supporting Clinton in 2016. Not your first choice? Too bad. Are you and your republic better off today for your having sat out? Unless you were playing the long game to exacerbate conditions to prepare the way for the coming revolution, you were being petulant and irresponsible.
  • Barnabas62Barnabas62 Shipmate, Host Emeritus
    The Establishment was the enemy. Hillary was an Establishment Democrat. Who still got 3 million more votes than Trump. Just not in the right States. I think Trump got the anti Establishment votes and abstentions where they counted.

    Is Kamala Harris an Establishment Democrat? Maybe. But I think the anti Trump dimension will be more significant this time. He will keep his 40% die hard loyalists. But I think Kamala will have a positive impact on the 10-15% floating voters who will decide this.
  • Barnabas62 wrote: »
    The Establishment was the enemy. Hillary was an Establishment Democrat.
    Irrelevant. Trump, despite being batshit crazy, is establishment. A snowflake has a better chance of surviving on a hot day in Hell's desert than any of the other candidates had of winning.
    Barnabas62 wrote: »
    Who still got 3 million more votes than Trump.
    Just not in the right States.
    People keep saying this and it might be emotional comfort, but it doesn't matter. The stupid bastards that voted for anyone other than Clinton, or the mind-numbingly braindead people who didn't vote, still pushed Trump over the line.
    Barnabas62 wrote: »
    But I think Kamala will have a positive impact on the 10-15% floating voters who will decide this.
    I hope so. But my faith in humanity to shove sticks up their own arses makes me pessimistic.

  • OhherOhher Shipmate
    Barnabas62 wrote: »
    But I think the anti Trump dimension will be more significant this time. He will keep his 40% die hard loyalists. But I think Kamala will have a positive impact on the 10-15% floating voters who will decide this.

    All well and good, but let's bear in mind that it's not just the vote count that's needed here; it's votes from the right voters in the right states. Hillary Clinton *lost* the 2016 election with a 3,000-vote majority.

  • No, 3 million
  • stetsonstetson Shipmate
    lilbuddha wrote: »
    Barnabas62 wrote: »
    The Establishment was the enemy. Hillary was an Establishment Democrat.
    Irrelevant. Trump, despite being batshit crazy, is establishment.

    Economically, yes, Trump is establishment. But I think what people mean when they say he's not establishment is that he's an outsider as far as the political establishment goes. IOW he didn't rise to power via the usual channels in DC or state capitals. He basically went from Manhattan landlord to TV show host to president with no stops at city hall, state capital, congress, or a military barrack. That gives him a very different public image than someone like Hillary Clinton, or indeed anyone has served as president.


  • lilbuddhalilbuddha Shipmate
    edited August 2020
    stetson wrote: »
    lilbuddha wrote: »
    Barnabas62 wrote: »
    The Establishment was the enemy. Hillary was an Establishment Democrat.
    Irrelevant. Trump, despite being batshit crazy, is establishment.

    Economically, yes, Trump is establishment. But I think what people mean when they say he's not establishment is that he's an outsider as far as the political establishment goes. IOW he didn't rise to power via the usual channels in DC or state capitals. He basically went from Manhattan landlord to TV show host to president with no stops at city hall, state capital, congress, or a military barrack. That gives him a very different public image than someone like Hillary Clinton, or indeed anyone has served as president.
    Image is a fucking stupid reason to vote for someone. And Jesus, is a lack of qualification being seen as a plus the most asinine reason available.

  • OhherOhher Shipmate
    No, 3 million

    CORRECT. My bad. Not enough coffee this morning; apologies.
  • tclunetclune Shipmate
    No, 3 million

    No, it was a 3 million vote plurality.
  • CrœsosCrœsos Shipmate
    Twilight wrote: »
    During the debates she told a story about herself, "I was that little girl on a bus" that was obviously pre-planned, the T-shirts had been printed and were sold after the debate. It presented an image to Americans of a poor African-American child, a descendant of slaves rising up from poverty. The truth is she grew up with great privilege, her father was a college professor, an immigrant whose grandparents had been slave holders in Jamaica.

    You know, a lot of descendants of slaves have ancestors who were slaveholders (e.g. the descendants of Sally Hemings).
    Twilight wrote: »
    Add to all this her beauty and looks that can pass for white . . .

    Not well enough to fool Berkeley Public Schools, apparently.
Sign In or Register to comment.