Questions about the Anglican Church of Canada
GuiltyOfDust
Shipmate Posts: 26
Hello all,
I am an American Episcopalian, but my partner is a Canadian, so I spend about half of my weekends in the GTA. I attend the local ACC parish when I am there.
I am looking to learn a bit more about the flavor of the ACC, and particularly to learn more about the prayer book they use. I am a bit confused by the BAS: is it an official prayer book?
What are the similarities and differences between the ACC and TEC?
Any insight or resources for an American looking to learn more would be greatly appreciated.
I am an American Episcopalian, but my partner is a Canadian, so I spend about half of my weekends in the GTA. I attend the local ACC parish when I am there.
I am looking to learn a bit more about the flavor of the ACC, and particularly to learn more about the prayer book they use. I am a bit confused by the BAS: is it an official prayer book?
What are the similarities and differences between the ACC and TEC?
Any insight or resources for an American looking to learn more would be greatly appreciated.
Tagged:
Comments
The ACC in light of the split in the US over the 1979 Prayer Book decided to authorize a modern Prayer Book under the name Book of Alternative Services. The traditional 1962 Prayer Book is still fully authorized. It's a fudge to keep everyone happy.
Canadian churches in general and the Anglican, United and Presyterian churches in particular tend to look and act much more like their English and Scottish parents rather than their American sisters. The ACC isn't especially Low but it isn't especially High either. But as the ACC has a much larger share of the population than TEC has proportionately it retains more of a middle-of-the-road Church of England feel.
Some of the things TEC did very early on to distinguish itself from the Church of England never applied in Canada. This is one of the many ecclesiastical effects of the American Revolution.
You're probably in a better position to speak to that than we are. :-)
Basically the prayer book situation is, as SPK said, a fudge - think about an alternate history in which TEC had brought in the 1979 BCP while allowing the 1928 to co-exist with it, and parishes today used one or the other, or a combination of both, as they chose.
In terms of the books themselves: as a norm, until more or less the mid-20th C, global Anglican churches published prayer books that were gently edited adaptations of Cranmer's 1662 BCP. The TEC 1928 BCP is one of many examples. The Canadian 1962 was either the last of these internationally, or close to the last. The BAS, though it includes a Cranmer-lite Communion service, is mostly modern-language.
The 1662 Book of Common Prayer drew on earlier Cramnerian English though.
That rather understates the case. The language of the 1662 book is very substantially that of Cranmer’s 1549 and 1552 books. The changes are relatively minor and mostly not about the language used.
But I take your point.
The 1662 BCP, which drew heavily from Cranmer's work.
The ACC had a significant element in the laity who were born in Emgland and the 1662 style is what they knew and expected.
Augustine tbe Aleut knows more than me, but Canadian Anglicans in rhe 19th and 20th Centuries rather saw themselves as Establishment "Not Roman Catholics" with a Prayer Book.
Apologies for my pedantry.
Apologies GuiltyOfDust but there just aren't that many Canadians here on the Ship and a good portion of the frequent posters, like myself, aren't Anglicans.
I’m most familiar with Canadian Anglicanism but lived in the US for a few years so have some basis for comparison. When I was in the US I was living in three different cities and attending three very different parishes and my sense is that there wide variety of Anglican/Episcopalian expression in both countries, some more to my taste than others. As others have said, the BAS is an authorized book and now more commonly seen than the 1962 BCP. It also has a rite with the older language. I’m not entirely sure about its relationship with the UK ASB but I would not be surprised if they had similar origins.
Happy to answer any more specific questions that I can answer, as I’m sure others would be as well, but I think it is hard to generalize about similarities and differences when there is a lot of diversity within both organizations.
I suspect (without any first hand knowledge whatsoever) that Canadian Anglicanism might be a bit like that, but also (perhaps because of the hangover of Empire) be a bit more like the C of E too. Is there any truth in that?
I think something that the ACC and ECUSA may have in common is that the hardline conservative tendencies within both organizations have generally found other homes over the last 50 years, perhaps unlike the CofE.
* known not so affectionately as the Bloody Awful Service book. It may be no coincidence that my Tablet autocorrected "BAS" to " BAD" ... 😈
I am. Longing, dreamy sigh…
... and as a Weapon of Mass Destruction ...
Cranmer's collects also set new standards for Uriah Heap-ism in prayer form.
I know he is loved, and turned many beautiful phrases, but I do feel it is frequently overdone.
Can you provide an example? (I’m serious.)
Almighty and most merciful Father; We have erred, and strayed from thy ways like lost sheep. We have followed too much the devices and desires of our own hearts. We have offended against thy holy laws. We have left undone those things which we ought to have done; And we have done those things which we ought not to have done; And there is no health in us. But thou, O Lord, have mercy upon us, miserable offenders. Spare thou them, O God, who confess their faults. Restore thou them that are penitent; According to thy promises declared unto mankind in Christ Jesu our Lord. And grant, O most merciful Father, for his sake; That we may hereafter live a godly, righteous, and sober life, To the glory of thy holy Name. Amen.
Others may not find this objectionable, but especially when actually reciting it, it always struck me as having a certain unpleasant relish to it, with each successive phrase being a fresh self-excoriation. When it gets a look-in, the mercy is entirely conditional and somehow far from warm - God still has to be observed at all times, like an angry cat, for the next time whatever one is doing might make him lash out.
"We do not presume to come to this thy Table, O merciful Lord, trusting in our own righteousness, but in thy manifold and great mercies. .... ".
I like that prayer and think it is a pity that one gets given the opportunity to say it less frequently these days.
I can see your point with the General Confession, though, again, I like it. By the standards of the sixteenth century, and several after it, it is relatively mild. It has always struck me that there is no simpler summary of what confession is about than,
"We have left undone those things which we ought to have done; And we have done those things which we ought not to have done;"
That has got it all. None of the mealier mouthed modern replacements are a patch on it.
@Sober Preacher's Kid are you referring primarily to the influence of the Scottish church on Samuel Seabury?
Totally agree with you. It's very dear to my heart, as I am a personal devotee of the '28 prayer book which uses that same prayer.
Yes and no, it really depends on where you are regionally. In the Deep South most Episcopal churches are more Evangelical (in the old sense) and low church.
In large cities around the country you are liable to find Anglo-Catholics, Inclusive Orthodox, and the Liberal Catholics. Although the latter wing is waning.
As does Enoch, we like this and add our liking of the prayer of humble access.
In re the waning of liberal catholics, I invite a comparison with the Norfolk Broads. In dry years, freshwater plants are driven out as the salt water of the North Sea encroaches. This is not because of any deficiency in the nature of the fresh water - the conditions for the plants' survival are just no longer there. This is what we have seen already in the Church of England - in the face of Evangelical invasion (and this, at least in England is a plot which has existed since the 1950s, and the Keele Gathering) - the conditions for survival of liberal catholicism are being destroyed, and those who would be attracted by it no longer have a home in the church.
We do not presume to come to your table, merciful Lord,
trusting in our own goodness,
but in your all-embracing love and mercy.
We are not worthy even to gather up the crumbs under your table,
but it is your nature always to have mercy.
So feed us with the body and blood of Jesus Christ, your Son,
that we may forever live in him and he in us. Amen.
I sometimes wonder if things could have been done better with different options for different audiences. The 1962 book was unquestionably in need of revision by the 1980s and generally it seems to be that a liturgy needs to evolve in order to survive. (Which is a problem for the 1962 book which now seems almost set in amber and practically speaking unrevisable in any way.) But as I say the revisers of the 1980s BAS seemed to looking for something very different in overall feel from the BCP tradition - a change that I’m sure many Anglicans at the time desperately wanted to happen but was deeply alienating for others.
At our place we have both an earlier straight-BAS Sunday Mass and a later Mass which is a bit of a mishmash as far as I can tell - not straight out of either book but more BCP than BAS, except e.g. where there is a baptism where the modern rite is used for that part of the service.
And the 2000 General Convention adopted a resolution that “the texts of the Daily Offices and Holy Communion contained in the 1928 edition of The Book of Common Prayer remain available for occasional use under the ecclesiastical authority subject to the guidelines for supplemental liturgical materials.” So again, the 1928 BCP can’t be used exclusively, but can be used if the bishop allows it.
It’s not quite the same as both editions being authorized and parishes being free to choose which to use. But assuming a bishop consents, a parish could choose to use the 1928 BCP rather than the 1979 BCP at least some of the time.
There is also a 1962 language communion rite in the BAS in Canada so in principle a parish could use the BAS exclusively while exclusively using a 1962-language communion service. My recollection is that this wasn’t particularly encouraged and parishes that wanted to keep the old language generally kept using the BCP. (There was no similar provision for Morning and Evening prayer.)
I once had a clash with an American 'Hagin' type health-wealth pastor about it online.
I am reluctant to use the 'h' word but have little hesitation to deploy it in that direction.
That said, I can understand @ThunderBunk's reservations but wouldn't want to see it dropped. I like the Presbyterian version @Nick Tamen shared too.
The Orthodox pre-communion prayers may strike some people as being somewhat grovelly too but I don’t see them that way. Like the Anglican general confession and the 'prayer of humble access' they are salutary reminders I think.
Presumably this bidding from the BAS order for Good Friday (page 310) would be unusual in TEC: "For Elizabeth our Queen and all the Royal Family, for N the Prime Minister and for the government of this country, for N the premier of this province and the members of the legislature..."
(Though for my own personal piety, I was praying for protection from members of the Royal Family such as Andrew, but did not feel the need to mention that out loud.)
Otherwise, what Marsupial noted seems correct to me: there wide variety of Anglican/Episcopalian expression in both countries.
Perhaps your prayers have been answered @Leaf insofar that Mr Andrew Mountbatten-Windsor is no longer Prince.
That’s not unlike the Canadian experience where in a typical Anglican parish you’re much more likely to see the BCP used at a weekday or 8:00 Sunday morning service. The difference is that there are still a number of mainstream ACC parishes that consistently use physical purple books (ie the actual BCP) for a principal service on Sunday, whereas my experience in the US was that everyone was using the 1979 book though they may have been using the older language version of the communion service in that book.
Although the resolution adopted by General Convention in 2000 would appear to suggest there was still some demand for the 1928 prayer book in 2000. But even that was 26 years ago now.
Ditto, times a million. I’m not happy that there isn’t a “modern language” version of the prayer of humble access in the 1979 BCP, Rite II. It’s technically optional even in Rite I, so why not include as a possibility in Rite II? It’s 100% solid, good, accurate theology.
Even for horrible people, perhaps especially for horrible people, one can and should still pray, along with protection from them.
The original version of this resolution, which came from the Standing Commission on Liturgy and Music, stated: General Convention appears to have decided, rather than having possible differences from diocese to diocese, to direct the SCLM to prepare texts.
The 82nd General Convention meets next year (2027) in Phoenix.
I suspect the more likely explanation is that the number of Episcopalians enthusiastic about getting up very early on a Sunday morning to go to church isn’t particularly large and didn’t overlap in any obvious way with people who preferred the 1928 book.
Honestly, the way you described it, the decision sounds like the ecclesiastical version of a network deciding to cancel a show by putting it in an unpopular time slot on its schedule.
The one exception to that experience of who was most likely to attend midweek services was a university-town parish that had Evening Prayer every weekday, which was primarily attended by students and faculty/staff rather than older people. But they used Rite II from the 1979 BCP for that.
The 10:45 service gradually withered as the older generation died out. I do remember being asked by one concerned at 10:45-er why no young people came to the service. When the 9:15 service started back in the 1980s it had been popular with young families who in turn were those who resourced and used the Sunday school.
Yay!